Sunday, March 1, 2009

My 5 for Your 5, Part I

OK, lest we get too serious and work-oriented here on this blog, let me try for a bit levity (and, by the way, do feel free to start your own new thread of conversation via a new posting: you'll just have the pressure of coming up with a good title!). We'll eventually watch a film later in the semester, and in anticipation of that maybe you'd be willing draw from your moviegoing careers and nominate your Top 5 films (it doesn't necessarily have to be the best five films, as you'll see from my list, but might also include films that just represented a memorable moviegoing experience). Annotations are optional (and maybe next we'll try music). This is difficult and provisional, but here's an attempt:

  • Wings of Desire (Wim Wenders' most transcendent film; haunting, poetic, beautiful story about an angel who decides to give up immortality to become human)
  • Jaws (I can never get enough of this one, perhaps because, while still thrilled by the narrative, I increasingly appreciate the craft and the genius of the filmmaking. It's also probably the most memorable "film event" of my life: my grandparents took me to see it as an eleven year-old, against my mother's strict warning that they not do so! I remember wearing brand new sneakers that night, which ensured that my visceral discomfort stretched from head to toe. Incidentally, my grandparents would further enrage my mother by taking me, the following summer, to see Tarzan -- the version where Bo Derek is naked for about 100 minutes; this film (but for Bo, of course) would undoubtedly be in my list of Top 5 most horrible films I've ever seen).
  • The English Patient (This would probably also be in my Top 5 literary works list. I'm a sucker for this film. I was so sad when I learned that the director, Anthony Minghella, died suddenly last year; he was an amazing talent. This is one of those rare cases when book and film nourish and augment each other in the best of ways).
  • It's a Wonderful Life (Does it need a justification? Is there a film with a bigger emotional payoff at the end than this one?)
  • Cinema Paradiso (This is perhaps the most flawed of the five films I include, but you have to love a film that celebrates the love of film. And it comes with its own wallop of an emotional payoff during the poignant coda)

It's painful to leave out Peter Jackson's stirring Lord of the Rings films, as well as the first Alien film (sci-fi suspense doesn't get any better), and somehow I feel Star Wars should be in the running merely because of the movie experience it offered to this then twelve year-old ("You're all clear, Kid, now let's blow this thing and go home!" ah, the goosebumps!) -- it's also the only film I ever saw more than twice (five times, in fact) in the theater ... And I've neglected comedies ... Anyway, have at it ... if you'd like!

16 comments:

  1. I'm re-posting Travis's comment :

    Wow. How does someone narrow down their selections of films to five. That is tough, but here goes, in no particular order.

    Return of the King- I loved the first two movies and I can't get enough of the books, but this film, the intensity of it all and the real human drama (I know it's fantasy, but good fantasy appeals to real life) made this film for me. Not to mention, thought, the score by Howard Shore which still has some of my favorite pieces of music.

    The Nightmare Before Christmas- Tim Burton + Danny Elfman = the greatest director/composer combination in cinematic history. This film also describes much of who I was in high school. I did things that others never understood why I wanted to do them and when some tried it, they never understood what was done. They did not see what was really going on. But overall, Danny Elfman's music and voice make this film one of my top ones.

    Goonies- If there was ever a movie that depticts kids as they are, this one is it. Though this would never happen, I could easily see my friends and I embark on some adventure like this. That is how we would have acted and lets not forget the movies is down right funny. It also has some of the greatest one liners I can think of in a movie (except for Tommy Boy and Monty Python and the Holy Grail, but these movies won't make my list).

    Transformers- Nostalgia, Nostalgia, Nostalgia. That is what this film means for me. I remembered watching Transformers when it was on as I watched this movie. It was everything I wanted a Transformers movie to be. So much in fact, I am a psycho about the second one and know just about everything there is to know about it when it comes out. Yeah, I need a life.

    Now for the best two films ever. In no particular order.

    Hoosiers- Probably the greatest sports movie ever made. And it is about basketball, my first love of sports. A small town sports team, with a high school of about sixty students, going up against the biggest and best high schools in Indiana and winning. Wow. That rocks. It is difficult for me to even describe it.

    Remember the Titans- I lived in Roanoke, Virginia, which is about forty minutes above where this film takes place, for a short bit of time and so this movie rang home with me when I saw it. There is no other film, to me, which portrays the struggles of racism and of friendship so well. There is also no other film that shows human struggle as being so human. I can relate to what some of these people went through, though not on the same scale, as I have been on the receiving end of racism and find it utterly dispicable. I hope all who have seen this movie feel the same way.

    These last two films I had to put together. I can't decide between these two. Choosing between them would be akin, but not equal, to deciding which of my kids I love best. So that's why I have six movies.

    Travis Burnham, 7:26 p.m. (3/1/09)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Okay, so, it's past my bedtime so I'll have to keep this brief but I couldn't resist this topic.

    Amelie- This is the first movie that I loved enough to buy it on DVD so that I could watch it whenever I felt like it. The story is moving, the characters are beautiful and it has one of the best first kiss scenes ever. Also, the cinematography is breathtaking.

    Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind- This film is captures the beauty and anguish of love and relationships in such an unusual way. The acting is spectacular and the concept is refreshing.

    Il Postino- Poetry, love, Spain, Neruda. What more can I say?

    Stranger than Fiction- First of all, I'm a sucker for any comedian who attempts a more serious role. Will Ferrel as a taxman?! You've got to love it. Plus, it's a story about writing and all that goes into creating a world from scratch.

    Once- This movie just seems so real and accessible to me. I was incredibly moved by it. In fact, besides Amelie, it's the only other movie I own.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Eesh, it is late, so I will also keep this quite short.

    Kill Bill and Pulp Fiction. (Tarantino is my hero)

    Ghost World. (stunning, and full of sarcasm.)

    Fight Club. (I am Jack's broken heart.)

    The Royal Tenenbaums. (and the Life Aquatic, I just absolutely love Wes Anderson)

    Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. (I just loved it, and it has a sleepy sort of beauty, possibly because I watched it six times in a row, drifting in and out of sleep on a plane on my way back from Australia.)

    I actually just saw the English Patient for the first time today, and I cried like a baby. Beautiful.

    ReplyDelete
  4. All time top 5:
    1: - Fight Club. The genius of Chuck Palahniuk has never been more fully realized than in this film. Fight Club illustrates everything that a film should be- it's smart, engaging and informative - it's funny, it's real, the cinematography, special effects, lighting and score all kick ass, and the story is absolutely top notch. He also wrote "Stranger Than Fiction," but I really wish they'd turn more of his books into feature films (Lullaby and Diary would be the best I think).

    2; -Snatch. I know that as a guy I'm not supposed to like Brad Pitt, but he nails every unique character he plays (12 Monkeys, Meet Joe Black...). There isn't a trend here though - to me Snatch is Guy Richie's final draft of "Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels." The brilliant overlap of multiple storylines and a convoluted time line is something more characteristic of Tarantino, but I feel the method is fully realized in this great story.

    3; -High Fidelity. First rate adaptation of the Nick Hornby novel, which interestingly enough took place in England. John Cusack and Jack Black are amazing. This I think is the best break-up film (if you're a guy anyway) to wash the post-break-up blues away. Also this film is to music the way that "Sideways," is to wine. Very thought provoking and informative.

    4; -The Big Lebowski. What can I say - the most quotable movie of all time. Lebowskifest takes place every year (this year it's in May in LA) and the Coen brothers continue to gain popularity from this eclectic masterpiece of riveting dialogue.

    5; -The Dark Night. -"A sly declaration of new classic status slipped into a bunch of safe ones..." I don't know about everyone else, but this film impressed me like modern cinema lacks the capacity to do 99.9 per cent of the time. Heath Ledger's performance wasn't only equal to Jack Nicholson's as the joker - in my opinion he vastly surpassed it. Of course he did - the director made him look at Francis Bacon art for a month to get in character! It wasn't Heath Ledger playing the joker - it was the Joker, in the flesh. Excellent stylistic plot alterations as well - the Batman movies from the 90's were about on the same par as the SAW movies - a passing fad.

    It's hard not to neglect several works - I have to agree with Eric on Star Wars - although I believe Empire Strikes Back is in general the best one (mostly because George Lucas had nothing to do with it).
    Also a huge Jim Carrey fan, and it was difficult to omit brilliant works like "Eternal Sunshine," and, "The Truman Show."

    *apologies for the obscene length of this reply.

    ReplyDelete
  5. These are in no particular order.

    2001: A Space Odyssey

    Lola Rennt (Run Lola Run)

    American Beauty

    Trainspotting

    Gegen die Wand (Head-On)

    Runner(s) Up:

    A Clockwork Orange

    Amores Perros (Love's a Bitch)

    No Country for Old Men

    ReplyDelete
  6. Being a film-phile, this is going to be difficult. I totally agree with everyone else's choices, so I'll make mine a little different:

    1. What Dreams May Come -- Kind of a lesser known Robin Williams movie about a man who meets his soul mate and loses his children in a horrible wreck, only too soon before his own death. The whimsical landscape of Heaven and Hell is haunting. And I just love how Williams ventures into Hell to find his wife (who has just committed suicide), while reminiscing on the events that prepared him for this fateful journey.

    2. Atonement -- Despite being one of my favorite books of all time, the film version also captivates all of the emotions I had while reading the book: hopeful, devastated, intrigued. The "love story" is really quite minimal, but it becomes the core later on as the main character, Briony Tallis, must "atone" for what she's done to the lives of her sister and her sister's lover. Very poignant, and the 5 1/2 minute shot of Dresden Beach leaves you with chills.

    3. City Lights -- I just recently saw this movie, and I couldn't believe how much of an emotional impact a silent film could have on me! You have to love Charlie Chaplin's crazy antics as he tries to win the heart of the blind girl. Truly an endearing classic.

    4. The Hours -- It really helps to read Virginia Woolf's "Mrs. Dalloway" to catch all the allusions. The story itself is so creative, taking three snapshots of three different women: a lesbian in the present giving a party (Meryl Streep), a pregnant housewife in the '50s struggling with depression (Julianne Moore), and of course, Virginia Woolf (Nicole Kidman) currently working on "Mrs. Dalloway" that will prove to have consequences over the two other women. Having kind of a soft spot for Virginia Woolf (one of my favorite authors), I always choke up during the beautifully executed scene of her writing a final letter to her husband, and then drowning herself.

    5. Across the Universe -- I have a strange affinity for crazy/artsy musicals (take Moulin Rouge for instance). I particularly liked this take on Beatles songs. I remember watching this for the second time with my parents (who grew up in the Vietnam War era), and really feeling the power of symbolism when Max and the other men drafted into the army carry the Statue of Liberty through a Vietnamese jungle singing, "She's So Heavy." Quite breath-taking.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Can't... resist... talking about myself and the things I like... Damnit I'm giving in.

    No Order:

    Equilibrium- The Matrix can go off and die because this movie kicks it's buttocks even with a low budget.

    The Machinist- If anyone ever doubted Christian Bale (as I've done) watch this movie and bow down.

    Reservoir Dogs- Not only is Tarantino an amazing writer/director but he can compose a symphony of violent beauty in celluliod format on only $30,000.

    Flawless- Robert Dinero (need I say more) and Philip Hoffman in drag (again need I say more!)

    V for Vendetta- What an incredible movie and my knees go weak for Hugo Weaving anyways, so it's kinda win-win.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey reptar,

    I just read your top 5 movies and I wondered: have you've taken Sean O'brien's intro to film class? If not, you should because she shows several of those films in her class and offers them up as fine specimens to disect and examine...

    ReplyDelete
  9. Sullivan's Travels
    Sunset Blvd
    Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
    Munich
    Schindler's List
    The Deer Hunter
    Amelie
    Duck Soup
    Raising Arizona
    Manhattan

    I have a hard time time following directions. So I put ten down instead of five. I hate not Jaws on the list though. That movie is very quotable.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I'm going to ditto some others...On my list to watch at least once a year:

    It's a Wonderful Life - Shame on you if you've never watched this classic.

    Moulin Rouge - Art incarnate

    Star Wars - (only the old ones...I am sort of in love with Hans Solo (the original)and if he's not in the film, forget it)

    The Sound of Music - Sappy and fabulous

    The Never Ending Story - I would love to have a personal luck dragon

    ReplyDelete
  11. I haven't taken her intro to film class, but I took a one credit seminar film class last semester. I'd seen most of the movies prior to taking it (with the exception of sling blade and once). I was bummed she didn't show Mulholland Drive or Blue Velvet; she mentioned that they had both been shown previous years...either would make for...interesting...discussion. Are you a media arts major by chance? Or did you just take the class for fun?

    ReplyDelete
  12. There are increasingly a lot of great films represented here. I, too, liked "American Beauty" a lot: that scene of the kid filming that plastic bag floating on the wind down the sidewalk, making it into a kind of work of art, was one of the most brilliant individual scenes I can remember. I think I have to watch "Eternal Sunshine..." again, since I was bit sleepy the time I watched it and probably didn't appreciate it properly. I liked "Atonement," too, but I tend to think of that as a lesser version of "The English Patient" (you know, the war-time historical romance w/buried secrets model). And "The Hours": yes, great, great film, and very poignant.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Oh how I love lists:

    1. Amelie : the one and only movie I have been able to watch a billion times and still feel warm and smily from.

    2. The Royal Tennembaums (and by this addition to the list I invisibly add every other Wes Anderson movie as well) : Great actors, great soundtrack

    3. Welcome to the Dollhouse : I feel horrible laughing at this movie, but it still gets me every time. I see something of myself in the main character I suppose.

    4. Lost In Translation : What caused my truest love for Bill Murray to begin, and the movie that made me gain respect for Scarlett Johanssen and her loveliness.

    5. Sister Act II: There is nothing, and I repeat nothing, better than inspirational montage scenes and heartwrenching musical endings. Plus Lauryn Hill is in it, and her voice is too good not to love the whole movie.

    ReplyDelete
  14. So many suggestions, I think I will just name one movie that I know is well worth watching.
    It's called "BRICK" and it's a fascinating mystery about a high-mimetic brainiac character who is a nobody. The most extraordinary feature of this movie is the language. Given it is englsih, but an old english. Almost all the characters are in high school and they speak as though they live in the 1930's, but it takes place in modern times. Also the setting more or less portrays an economical and social depression.

    ReplyDelete
  15. All right i came late to this post but i'll post anyway...

    5. Hot Fuzz/Sean of the Dead
    I'll group these because they are very similar and contain quite a few of the same people. Both are humor-driven action movies that parody a genre of film as well as parody themselves.

    4. Boondock saints. I'm tired of Fight Club being praised, it really wasn't that good. It's quotable but nowhere near the genius of Boondock saints. The shining star is Willem Defoe who (blasphemy i know) could outdo heath ledger as the joker. Two people i work with actually got the latin tattoos because of this movie.

    3. Dark Star. Low budget college film studies final project crapola. And simultaneously one of the greatest "indie" films of all time.

    2. Southland Tales. No one that i have shown this movie to has liked it at all. Which is sad, as i feel it deserves to be shown. This movie is a re-imagining of the book of Revelations set in 2007. Genius.

    1. Sunshine. Most Sci-fi has a bad rep, it tends to be either arcane or such a sell-out (star wars) that it has lost respect as a genre. Sunshine changes that, it is a study of human nature (most good sci-fi is)that echoes a Ray Bradbury story called "The Golden Apples of the Sun". Oh and Wikipedia says that the Bradbury story is from a poem called "Song of Wandering Aengus" by Yeats. Even if sunshine devolves into cheap slasher movie for about seven minutes, the majority is truly beautiful and the music ethereal.

    ReplyDelete
  16. A bit late, sure, but here they are, in no order.

    Fur: An Imaginary Portrait of Diane Arbus.
    (Glorious cast, beautiful cinematography, and embracing one's inner freak.)

    Buffy the Vampire Slayer
    (Oh yes, it is a horrible movie with horrible acting and a horrible script...but it started the show!)

    Amelie
    (This requires no more justification, as it has been previously mentioned)

    Pan's Labyrinth
    (I love fairy tales, I suppose. Grim ones even moreso.)

    The Triplets of Belleville
    (The most beautiful animation I've ever seen with an undeniably brilliant story...and it's nearly a silent film!)

    ReplyDelete